Dinner at Washington Square Tavern was another one of those "its good, but..." experiences. The food was very good, but it was overshadowed by some negatives. The Tavern broke the cardinal rule of restaurants...Don't forget the appetizers. Shortly after ordering, our burgers arrived and we were both wondering what happened to the cod fritters. When we alerted the food runner of the mistake, the fritters appeared table side in minutes. Thank goodness because they were excellent. The smoked cod gives them a very rustic flavor, and made a great side dish for the burgers too.
We both ordered the burger with cheddar; rare and medium well. Heather's first reaction was "thats a lot of meat!" Really thats what she said. The truffled fries were crispy, but with the slightest flavor of truffle.
Overall the burger was great and despite the negatives we would go back.